May 1, 2020
Right before the 40 day COVID-19 lockdown period was about to end, the Government of India (GoI) has announced yet another extension with continued restrictions on inter-state travel. As we send this out to the press on Labour Day, we are receiving frantic calls from workers desperate to return home. Without clarity on whether and how migrant workers can return home during this period, hunger, economic hardships, and mental trauma are already rising. GoI is putting out confusing messages by first granting migrants the permission to travel and two days later announcing that there will be no air and rail travel during the extended lockdown except for “select purposes”. Meanwhile, food, social security and monetary relief measures for migrant workers continue to be neglected by the GoI. With no relief measures, the permission for movement itself was being seen as the greatest relief. And now once again, migrant workers who are already on the brink of survival, are being put to yet another harsh test.
Since the lockdown, a group of around 100 volunteers formed the Stranded Workers Action Network (SWAN), and have been responding to distress calls from migrant workers across the country. In terms of relief, SWAN has been making small cash transfers to meet basic needs in addition to connecting workers to local organisations and the administration. A first report based on the work in the first phase of lockdown was released on 15th April. This second report by SWAN, released, titled 32 Days and Counting: COVID 19 Lockdown, Migrant Workers and the Inadequacy of Welfare Measures India, documents the experiences of migrant workers during the second phase of the lockdown period. This report has more detailed state specific conditions for some states and a timeline of announcements. The report is based on relief work and is NOT a survey. Within a few days of relief work, we decided to systematically document information and so the response rates to questions vary. Since March 27th, we have interacted with more than 1500 groups of stranded workers adding up to nearly 17,000 workers across the country and disbursed more than Rs 22.5 lakhs.
The lockdown decision announced on March 25th, while imminent, was unplanned and unilaterally made without any consultation with the state governments. The decision to extend the total lockdown without ramping up relief has only exacerbated the distress and anxiety among the migrant workers. While access to relief has marginally improved, largely due to civil society organisations, the distress continues. This time we also asked migrant workers two additional questions to assess their concerns once the lockdown ends and the immediate decision to stay or go home.
The main insights of the report based on worker testimonies are as follows:
Precarity remains high through the second phase of the lockdown as well. 50% of workers had rations left for less than 1 day.
46% of the groups that reached out were SOS calls with no food or money.
More than 4 out of 5 persons haven’t received rations in the second phase compared to 96% in the first phase. This improvement is also largely driven by some cases in Karnataka. 68% compared to 70% in the first phase had not received any cooked food
64% had less than Rs 100 left while 74% continue to have less than half their daily wages remaining to survive for the rest of the lockdown period.
Only 6% have been fully paid during the lockdown period and 16% have been partially paid. 78% have not been paid by their employers at all during the lockdown. 89% had not been paid at all in the first phase.
99% of the self-employed have had no income during the lockdown period.
41% said they will stay because they are anxious about unpaid rent, loans and no cash to travel or survive even at home.
One-third of the workers plan to continue in the same line of work or with the same employer, another one-third are unsure about what to do. Roughly 16 percent plan to leave and then return after some time, and about 13 percent plan to find work back in their hometown and about 5 percent want to earn some money and leave.
This initiative has been able to document only a fraction of the distress of migrant workers and extend only a fraction of the support they need. However, we hope that this report will amplify their experiences of the lockdown, and make the urgent case for universalising rations to all, wage compensation of Rs 7,000 per stranded worker for at least 3 months, and, full autonomy to migrant workers to stay or return home after dedicated, sanitised trains and buses with adequate medical teams in each train are organised, among several other immediate measures. The transportation should be free for the workers. The report includes worker testimonies, data and charts, and a detailed view from some states and cases of successful collaboration with administration and civil society in extending relief to migrants. We also offer some starting points for a deeper discussion on longer term measures for restoring the rights and dignity of workers, not just in the context of unprecedented emergencies like the COVID-19 pandemic.
For further details: Pease contact: